JP124: May Day

Scroll against the machine…

HaymarketRiot-Harpers.jpg(The Haymarket Riot, Harper’s Weekly –

“Eight Hours for Work, Eight Hours for Rest,
Eight Hours for What We Will!”

“The Haymarket Affair”, William J. Adelman, Illinois Labor History Society

No single event has influenced the history of labor in Illinois, the United States, and even the world, more than the Chicago Haymarket Affair. It began with a rally on May 4, 1886, but the consequences are still being felt today. Although the rally is included in American history textbooks, very few present the event accurately or point out its significance”

William J. Adelman

The 124

There’s a famous curse, which Bobby Kennedy dubiously designated a “chinese curse”,  which condemns: May you live in interesting times. These are interesting times. The “elected” executive of the most powerful government in history is a buffoonish, talentless, heir and the opposition party, the Democratic Party, long in decline, is hindered by a rift between the empowered neoliberal faction and a leftist, new deal uprising. A rash and reckless Republican Party should be easily contestable, but may continue to gain power due to the Democratic Party’s inability to reconcile its contradictions.

By influence of political history scholar, Thomas Frank,  it is my view that the only way to change the reactionary tide is for an authentic people’s party to emerge — be it the Democratic Party or otherwise.

Perhaps revisiting this nation’s illustrious, but too often neglected labor history could be a source of inspiration. In honor of May Day, this month’s 124 will be dedicated to heroes of the labor movement.

Labor Hero of the Week: Lucy Gonzalez Parsons

(Lucy Parsons 1920,

“Never be deceived that the rich will allow you to vote away their wealth”
-Lucy Parsons (1853-1942)

“More Dangerous Thana Thousand Rioters: The Revolutionary Life of Lucy Parsons”, Kelly Gallagher, The Nation

There is one word we should all be thinking in these first days under president-elect Donald Trump. One word that we should be shouting as we begin the work of combating the racist and misogynist policies that will inevitably come. One word we should embody now more than ever: Organize. Under Trump, we will need to come together in radically new ways, ways we haven’t even envisioned yet. In moments like these, artists have an especially unique role, actively encouraging community and care, critiquing misogyny and white supremacy, and resurrecting important histories of resistance and rebellion.

Weekly Roundup

“This May Day, Don’t Go to Work, Take to the Streets and Strike”, Michelle Chen, In These Times

From the Muslim ban to the border wall, President Donald Trump’s first 100 days have unleashed a blitzkrieg of terror. But on May 1, the communities he thought he’d backed into a corner will put him on the defensive with equal and opposite force.

Bernie Sanders with investigative journalist Jane Mayer, author of ‘Dark Money’, The Bernie Sanders Show

“‘Fear City’ Explores How Donald Trump Exploited The New York Debt Crisis to Boost His Own Fortune”, Naomi Klein, The Intercept

When I published “The Shock Doctrine” a decade ago, a few people told me that it was missing a key chapter in the evolution of the tactic I was reporting on. That tactic involved using periods of crisis to impose a radical pro-corporate agenda. They said that in the United States that story doesn’t start with Reagan in the 1980s, as I had told it, but rather in New York City in the mid-1970s. That’s when the city’s very near brush with all-out bankruptcy was used to dramatically remake the metropolis. Massive and brutal austerity, sweetheart deals for the rich, privatizations. In classic Shock Doctrine style, under cover of crisis, New York changed from being a place with some of the most generous public services in the country, engaged in some cutting-edge attempts at racial and economic integration, to the temple of nonstop commerce and gentrification that we all know and still love today.

“Black Politicians are Fighting a ‘Stand Your Ground’ Resurgence”, Mike Spies, The Trace

Soon after the start of his first term as a black lawmaker in the fifth-whitest state in the country, State Representative Ras Smith brought his hoodie to work. For the eleventh year in a row, elected officials in Iowa were going to take up a “stand your ground” proposal, authorizing residents to use lethal means to protect themselves in certain situations. In other states, similar laws have disproportionately justified the fatal shootings of African-Americans.

“Which Way to the Barricades?”, Steve Fraser and Nelson Lichtenstein, Jacobin

Rise, like lions after slumber,
In unvanquishable number,
Shake your chains to earth like dew
Which in sleep had fallen on you-
Ye are many—they are few.

Shelly’s “Masque of Anarchy” has been a spectral presence for nearly two hundred years, summoned at climactic moments of civil warfare. Composed to memorialize the 1819 Peterloo massacre, the poem commemorates the sixty thousand people who gathered at the very dawn of the industrial revolution to demand a radical expansion of suffrage, especially to those laboring in England’s dark satanic mills. Dozens died, hundreds were wounded.

“Brazil on Strike”, Lucas Iberico Lozada, Dissent

As darkness fell in Rio de Janeiro’s historic center on Friday evening, the smell of tear gas hung heavy. It had been a day of mass mobilization across the country: more than a million Brazilians in at least 254 cities participated in a day-long general strike on Friday, according to organizers; more are taking to the streets today for May Day, a national holiday here. The strike, said to be the biggest in decades, was meant to rally opposition to an aggressive pension reform plan that would weaken labor laws and raise the retirement age by a decade—the centerpiece of an array of austerity measures put forth by President Michel Temer, whose approval rating sits at a dismal 4 percent.

“Why Muslims are marching for climate”, Nana Firman, CNN

From the cropless farmer to the beleaguered first responder to the person forced to evacuate their flooded home, we all have our reasons for caring about climate change. As an Indonesian-born Muslim living in California, it is my faith that compels me to protect our earth.

“Gods of War”, Siddhartha Deb, The Baffler

When the Bengali poet Rabindranath Tagore flew in 1932 from Calcutta to Bushehr in Iran, he made a brief stop in Baghdad. It was a long journey, and although Tagore was extremely well traveled, this was only his second time on an aircraft. Seventy-one years old, curious about the world but critical of the violence and rigidity of modernity, Tagore was mostly unimpressed by his experience of commercial aviation. It brought to mind the mythical account in the Mahabharata of the warrior Arjuna being taken up into the air, making him reflect that Arjuna had lost intimacy with the earth by flying, his physical distancing resulting inevitably in a moral distancing that would allow him to kill from the air with­out compunction.

“Basic Income in a Just Society”, Birshen Rogers, Boston Review

“Amazon needs only a minute of human labor to ship your next package,” read a CNN headline last October. The company has revolutionized its warehouse operations using an army of 45,000 robots and other technologies. Previously workers known as “pickers” would walk among shelves to find goods. Now robots bring the shelves to them; pickers select goods, scan them, and put them into bins; after robots whisk the shelves away. A network of automated conveyer belts then sends the bins to “packers,” who spend just fifteen seconds on each, sealing boxes with tape that is automatically dispensed at the perfect length. “By the time you take an Amazon delivery off your stoop, walk into your home, find a pair of scissors and open the brown box,” the story intoned, “you’ve already spent nearly as much time handling the package as Amazon’s employees.”


Daniel Suhre, who writes the Unknown Minstrel section on this blarg has written some damn fine songs. No Minstrel this week, but y’all should check out the demos he has up on his bandcamp — special attention to the labor anthem, “May Day”, which has a verse for our Labor Hero of the Week Lucy Parsons.

“Ghost in the Shell”
Director: Mamoru Oshii
Cast: Atsuko Tanaka, Akio Otsuka, Koichi Yamadera

No real surprise that Rupert Sanders’  yellowfaced and superficial adaptation of “Ghost in the Shell” was a dud — good riddance. Let’s use this as an excuse to revisit Mamoru Oshii’s classic:

There are some complicated ideas explored in this film, here’s a great video from wisecrack to help out

…thank you for scrolling, comrades

JP124: Jury Duty

Take a quick scroll…

The 124 on Jury Duty

It’s been a busy few weeks, honest! First it’s Easter and now I have this jury duty summons! But excuses are like assholes, right? Or maybe that’s opinions. . . anyway, going to have to walk back my commitments to doing 124s on Terrorism and Israel/Palestine for the time being. Turns out they’re rather daunting and all time management problems aside, I’d like to devote a little more time to those two topics regardless. This week: The Roundup, Unknown Minstrel Week 5, and some baqia.

Weekly Roundup

“In Indonesia, pious “punks” promote Islam”, Tommy Ardiansyah, Johan Purnama, Kanupriya Kapoor, and Nick Macfie, Reuters

My knee jerk response to this headline was to remember the Christian Rock garbage I was encouraged to listen to at summer camp, the sort of music to which Hank Hill famously opined “You’re not making Christianity better, you’re making rock and roll worse!”. But comparative religions is risky business and I’m not here to be a critic. Interesting contrast to the Orientalist image.

Ahmad Zaki, one of the movement’s founders, believes the genre of punk is often associated with a “tendency towards misbehaviour” but he wants to change that.

“We can redirect ourselves to better, more positive things,” he said.

“The Airline Industry Is a Starving Giant That’s Gnawing at Our Economy”, Eric Levitz, New York Magazine

When the Carter administration began deregulating the airlines in the late ’70s, it did so in the name of fostering price competition. Sure, relinquishing public control might jeopardize smaller, rural cities’ access to convenient air travel, but free-market competition would also make flying more affordable for the vast majority of Americans.

But thanks in no small part to lax antitrust enforcement by President Reagan and his successors, deregulation ultimately turned a public quasi-monopoly into a private one.

War and Peace

“What We Do Best”, Patrick Blanchfield, n+1

Last night, on the centennial of America’s entry into World War I, President Donald Trump authorized the launch of fifty-nine Tomahawk missiles against a Syrian government military base. There has been no call for mass mobilization, no avuncular injunction to report to your local recruiting station. Donald Trump can launch $94 million of cruise missiles from the comfort of Mar-a-Lago; he does not Need You to do anything. But that won’t stop us.

“Trump’s Indonesian Allies In Bed with ISIS-Backed Militia Seeking to Oust Elected President”, Allan Nairn, The Intercept

Associates of Donald Trump in Indonesia have joined army officers and a vigilante street movement linked to ISIS in a campaign that ultimately aims to oust the country’s president. According to Indonesian military and intelligence officials and senior figures involved in what they call “the coup,” the move against President Joko Widodo (known more commonly as Jokowi), a popular elected civilian, is being impelled from behind the scenes by active and retired generals. . . .

. . . Like many officials I spoke with, Kivlan said that the current army-backed street movement and crisis began as a result of the Symposium, a 2016 forum organized by the Jokowi government that allowed survivors and descendants of ’65 to publicly describe what had happened to them and to discuss how their loved ones died. For much of the army, the Symposium was an intolerable outrage and in itself justified the coup movement. One general told me that what most outraged his colleagues was that “it made the victims feel good.” The Symposium, of course, had nothing to do with Gov. Ahok or with religious questions of any kind. It was about the army and its crimes.

Discrimination and Hate Crimes

“Chechen police ‘kidnap and torture gay men’ – LGBT activists”, Laurence Peter, BBC

Gay men are fleeing brutal persecution in Chechnya, where police are holding more than 100 people and torturing some of them in an anti-gay crackdown, Russian activists say.

Poverty and Class Struggle

“Investors are paying college students’ tuition — but they want a share of future income in return”, Frank Chaparro, Business Insider

Melissa Gillbanks is no fan of student loans, so when she was looking for a way to pay for her senior year at Purdue University, she was happy to sign away a portion of her future income in exchange for a very different way to raise cash for college.


“Oligarchy in America”, Andrew Levine, Counter Punch

Ironically, though, over the same period, income and wealth inequality and other problems associated with plutocracy have gotten worse; voting hasn’t helped with that at all.   Indeed, many less well off voters nowadays vote for candidates and policies that make the problems associated with plutocratic rule worse.  So much for expropriating the expropriators through the ballot box!

There are many reasons why this has happened: false consciousness comes immediately to mind; it is surely part of the explanation.  For evangelicals and others with retrograde social views in the United States, so is “values voting.”

But the most important part of the explanation, in the American case, is the lack of a real opposition party that the system in place does not thoroughly marginalize.  The Democratic Party is useless for that.  To be sure, even Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have been known to mouth off about the evils of inequality.  But you don’t need a bullshit detector to see that they are part of the problem, not part of the solution.


“Hundreds of Palestinians in Israeli jails begin hunger strike”, Nidal Almughrabi, Ori Lewis, Jeffrey Heller, and Alison Williams, Reuters

Hundreds of Palestinians in Israeli jails began a hunger strike on Monday in response to a call by prominent prisoner Marwan Barghouti, widely seen as a possible future Palestinian president.

Unknown Minstrel Week 5
By Daniel Suhre

Back at it again this week, this time returning to my PNW roots to pay homage to Kind of Like Spitting, a project of Ben Barnett that started around 1995 and lasted 10 or so years (with occasional releases/tours after 2006).

A friend introduced me to KOLS only last year, and what I found was a lot of music, probably created under less-than-ideal circumstances (though not without a sense of humor. Take a look at the cover of Professional Results:1999-2014 for instance).

What I like so much about Ben’s songwriting is he seems perfectly at home channeling Leonard Cohen as Death Cab for Cutie, and doesn’t get mired in purity struggles. On The Thrill of the Hunt we hear covers of much loved classics by Big Star (‘Thirteen’) alongside Dean Martin psuedo-deep cuts (‘Lay Some Happiness on Me’), all in an endearing bedroom folk configuration.

It’s telling that Ben chose to make an entire album of Phil Ochs covers. It was central to Phil’s music never to bow to the ideological demands of the folkies (Take, for example, the infamous Gunfight at Carnegie Hall album, a joyous romp of Elvis medleys and songs by Merle Haggard and Buddy Holly, complete with a telephone bomb threat, Phil smashing the box office window, and a three hour second set ended only by Carnegie Hall cutting the power).

I hear Ben’s music as somewhat of a continuation of Phil’s legacy. Class politics come through subtly on many KOLS releases, perhaps most pronounced on In the Red from 2005 (not coincidentally, this is my favorite KOLS album).

Around 2009, Ben started releasing songs with the band Blunt Mechanic, so more recordings to check out there. For now, listen to Sherriff Ochs (presumably about Phil Ochs, though I can’t verify that) from In the Red.

“There’s more to life than lovers and chores / there’s more to life than an office at the top floor”


Jury Duty

In 10 minutes I’m going to sign in for my jury duty summons. While the timing is inconvenient, I’ve looked forward to jury duty since my 1st grade teacher Ms. Swenson was summoned in the spring of 1995. I hear it’s boring, but I’m also sappypleased to be doing my civic duty.

In honor of this life landmark, I’m posting the trailer to Pauly Shore’s Jury Duty, easily one of the funniest movies ever made about jury duty.

. . . thank you for scrolling

JP124: Orientalism

Take a nice scroll…

The 124 on Orientalism

d96e229552d0a9065bc81e6fead70eebc99c424d.jpgJean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres, The Grand Odalisque, 1814, oil on canvas (Musée du Louvre, Paris)

Orientalism. What is it? Once upon a time it could be found on the course bulletin of every major university and it indicated the study of the orient,  land typically encompassing north Africa, the Middle East, and East Asia.

Literature professor and founder of post-colonial studies at Colombia, Edward Said (sigh-Eid, not sed) , analyzed this academic tradition and redefined it as the cultural component of imperialism, by which Europeans distinguished themselves, the enlightened Occident, from the near and far east or exotic Orient. He theorized that emphasizing the exotic was effective as justification for the violence and brutality of imperialism.

To this day it remains as a cultural lens through which the West views and defines the East disallowing the East from representing itself. Interesting to me is how amorphous the depiction is. There is little consistency to the orientalist representation, which once upon a time was a picture of lavish overindulgence and unabated sensual appetites. Hardly recognizable next to the today’s representation of rigid reactionaries who value piety and punish pleasure.

If the concept of Orientalism is new to you, I would encourage you to keep it in mind the next time you see Muslims depicted in movies, television or the news. Are you seeing common people you can relate to or something more exotic or fanatical?

That’s my two cents and you should take it for exactly what’s it’s worth. Here are a couple videos to elaborate:

“Edward Said – Framed: The Politics of Stereotypes in News” — Al Jazeera English


“What is Orientalism” — Quran Speaks

Exploring Prejudice

Stereotypes are often reinforced by the process of confirmation bias, the demonstrated human propensity to favor information that confirms our beliefs over contradictions to them. A relevant example: if you believe that Muslims are typically pious reactionaries, then the image of Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi may be easier to recall than Safiyya Ally and Shabir Ally, even if you’ve been exposed to both. I think it illustrates it okay, but for more:

“Confirmation Bias”, David McRaney, You Are Not So Smart

The Misconception: Your opinions are the result of years of rational, objective analysis.

The Truth: Your opinions are the result of years of paying attention to information which confirmed what you believed while ignoring information which challenged your preconceived notions.

For the reading list

“Orientalism”, Edward Said ($9.50 used from Powell’s)

I first encountered “Orientalism” 8 years ago when I was studying Arabic in Morocco and we translated sections of the text from English into Arabic. Since then I’ve thumb through it a few times and have each time been impressed by Said’s profundity. After years of periodic grazing, I’ve finally purchased my own copy and will be reading it cover-to-cover very soon.

In the introduction, Said quotes from Italian marxist Antonio Gramsci’s “Prison Notebooks”, giving me one of my all time favorite quotes:

“The starting-point of critical elaboration is the consciousness of what one really is, and is ‘knowing thyself’ as a product of the historical processes to date, which has deposited in you an infinity of traces, without leaving an inventory. Therefore it is imperative at the outset to compile such an inventory.

Antonio Gramsci, “Prison Notebooks”

“Native Believer”, Ali Eteraz

By happenstance I came across Ali Eteraz’s novel “Native Believer” on KPFA’s “Against the Grain” podcast. It’s about a secular Muslim living in the United States. Here’s the NYT Books review:

Weekly Roundup

“When Marx Meets Islam”, Ma Tianjie, Foreign Policy

Almost every Chinese person with even a middle school education must, at some point, run into the famous statement about religion by Karl Marx: “Religion is the opiate of the masses.” It is enshrined in textbooks that introduce students to the philosopher’s materialistic interpretation of the world, which considers religion as a “fantasy” used by reactionary forces to disarm the revolutionary proletariat by promising salvation in the afterlife while preaching endurance in the current one.

“Top Democrats Are Wrong: Trump Supporters Were More Motivated By Racism Than Economic Issues”, Mehdi Hasan, The Intercept

IT ISN’T ONLY Republicans, it seems, who traffic in alternative facts. Since Donald Trump’s shock election victory, leading Democrats have worked hard to convince themselves, and the rest of us, that his triumph had less to do with racism and much more to do with economic anxiety — despite almost all of the available evidence suggesting otherwise.

War and Peace

“The Spoils of War: Trump Lavished With Media and Bipartisan Praise for Bombing Syria”, Glenn Greenwald, The Intercept

In every type of government, nothing unites people behind the leader more quickly, reflexively or reliably than war. Donald Trump now sees how true that is, as the same establishment leaders in U.S. politics and media who have spent months denouncing him as a mentally unstable and inept authoritarian and unprecedented threat to democracy are standing and applauding him as he launches bombs at Syrian government targets.

Climate Change and The Environment

“BLM Replaces Mountain Landscape Photo with Coal Seam on Home Page”, Kirk Siegler, NPR

On the top of its home page, the Bureau of Land Management, which manages more than 200 million acres of public land under the U.S. Department of the Interior, swapped out a photo of a young boy and his companion backpacking across a mountain meadow in favor of one showing a massive coal seam at a mine in Wyoming.



Public Health

“Trump’s EPA moves to dismantle programs that protect kids from lead paint”, Chris Mooney and Juliet Eilperin, The Washington Post

Environmental Protection Agency officials are proposing to eliminate two programs focused on limiting children’s exposure to lead-based paint, which is known to cause damage to developing brains and nervous systems.

Poverty and Class

“Don’t Blame the Boomers”, Matt Bruenig, Jacobin

I was inspired by this piece in the Boston Globe, about how baby boomers have ruined everything, to go into the Survey of Consumer Finances and see just how well the boomers are actually doing, at least as far as wealth goes. The answer, as with all things, is it depends on what class of boomer you are talking about. Rich boomers are doing well. Poor boomers are not.

“At U-Va., a ‘watch list’ flags VIP applicants for special handling”, T. Rees Shapiro, The Washington Post

The University of Virginia’s fundraising team for years has sought to help children of wealthy alumni and prominent donors who apply for admission, flagging their cases internally for special handling, according to documents obtained by The Washington Post.

American Oligarchs

“Blackwater founder held secret Seychelles meeting to establish Trump-Putin back channel”, Adam Entous, Greg Miller, Kevin Sieff, and Karen DeYoung, The Washington Post

The United Arab Emirates arranged a secret meeting in January between Blackwater founder Erik Prince and a Russian close to President Vladi­mir Putin as part of an apparent effort to establish a back-channel line of communication between Moscow and President-elect Donald Trump, according to U.S., European and Arab officials.

“Notorious Mercenary Erik Prince is Advising Trump from the Shadows” Jeremy Scahill, The Intercept

Erik Prince, America’s most notorious mercenary, is lurking in the shadows of the incoming Trump administration. A former senior U.S. official who has advised the Trump transition told The Intercept that Prince has been advising the team on matters related to intelligence and defense, including weighing in on candidates for the Defense and State departments. The official asked not to be identified because of a transition policy prohibiting discussion of confidential deliberations.

State Violence and The Carceral State

“Police Arrested This Cop Watch Activist — But Recorded Themselves By Accident”, George Joseph, The Nation

Last August, Jose LaSalle, a prominent New York City Cop Watch activist, was arrested after filming a stop-and-frisk near a housing project in the South Bronx. Though filming the police is legal, LaSalle was charged with “obstructing governmental administration.” LaSalle claims he was standing far away from the incident. To continue documenting his own arrest, the veteran activist left his two phones and a GoPro camera turned on and recording as he was being taken to a nearby police station.

“Video released of police killing Utah man, firing at him with his own gun”, Sam Levin, The Guardian

Utah police officers fatally shot a man after disarming him and then firing at him with his own gun, according to law enforcement officials and body-camera footage that captured more than a dozen bullets fired.

Unknown Minstrel — Week 5
By Daniel Suhre

Will be back next week. Promise!

In the meantime, check out….

“Goodbye, Oh Goodbye”, Andrew Jackson Jihad

Your Essay or Whatever-you-want-really Here

I’m encouraging you to start a news blog and then to share a little something that I can post right here. It’d be an exchange and I’ll send something to you too. This is a good idea. This is a fun idea.


Fifty years ago Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. gave his speech “Beyond Vietnam — A Time to Break Silence” much to the distress of his friends, allies, and political patrons. Criticizing Vietnam was a bridge too far for the American establishment and the next morning Dr. King was condemned by the press, the president, many Democrats, and much of white America. By his assassination a year later, he was penniless and unpopular. The last Gallup poll before his death showed him as having 32% positive and 63% negative approval rating.

The last couple years of Martin Luther King, Jr.’s life are largely overlooked; his legacy whitewashed in what Dr. Cornell West has called the “Santa Claus-ification”.

“Beyond Vietnam — A time to Break Silence”, Martin Luther King, Jr., April 4, 1967

“I knew that I could never again raise my voice against the violence of the oppressed in the ghettos without having first spoken clearly to the greatest purveyor of violence in the world today — my own government. For the sake of those boys, for the sake of this government, for the sake of the hundreds of thousands trembling under our violence, I cannot be silent.”

thank you for scrolling

JP124: Islamophobia

Scrolling so smooth like the butter on the muffins


The 124:

I shared this anecdote on February 4th and I’m bringing it up again, because this month I want focus on Islamophobia in the west.

I was chatting with a guy today and my studying Arabic came up. He cautiously asked me about my opinions of Islam. I told him that I’ve never met a Muslim that I didn’t like (not totally true, I’ve met A FEW Muslims I didn’t like) and gave my fair opinion, ya know, that they’re people. He seemed relieved. He told me that his wife is Muslim and that he was asking because his boss “doesn’t trust Islam” and “thinks Muslims are dangerous.” Though not too surprising, this is always disheartening to hear. What really struck me though, was that he had a lot of compassionate understanding for his boss. More than the boss deserves. He told me that this person was “just shell-shocked” after being a marine for XX years.

This isn’t the first time I’ve seen this sort of compassion from Muslims and their community. They’re so mistreated here. There doesn’t seem to be a limit to the cruelty, fear of, and disregard for Muslims in this country and the west in general. There’s a lot of kindness and solidarity, but too much callousness. Despite all this, despite being the victims of a long lists of western and American injustice, so often the cruelty is met with compassion — a lot of sadness and confusion too — but real compassion and mercy. It really moves me. Almost to tears. It then makes me angry. Furious at anyone who express enmity to the people of this faith. And that, in turn, embarrasses me. These Muslim victims of oppression respond with powerful compassion, but this little privileged man gets furious. What a mess.

In Islamophobia I see a greater and lesser evil. The greater evil is the most critical and refers to the effect that this fear and hatred of Muslims has on the Muslims themselves. The anecdote above is one such example that fits on a spectrum spanning the infliction of terror and insecurity,  outright attacks on Muslim symbols and institutions, actual violence against Muslim people, and the founding of a cultural background that enables torture, more than a decade of war, and the near complete disregard for Muslim lives.

The lesser evil begs attention too. That evil is the one that harms those who hold the prejudice and it wounds twice. First it wounds in the way that any prejudice twists and corrupts its bearer’s heart. Fear and hatred of the other stokes and exacerbates a very ugly part of the human psyche. What’s worse is that the sense of superiority it cultivates can be intoxicating and addicting. This is why, I think, folks who give in to a prejudice like Islamophobia have such a hard time letting go. The other wound is that it robs the prejudiced person of a rich and profound culture. I have an infinite appetite for beauty of this world. I pity any who close themselves off to a treasure in favor of the poisonous intoxicant of prejudice.

I intend to devote some time to both evils, but the greater evil is of more importance. Islamophobia hurts people; makes them feel unwelcome and unsafe. My relationships with Muslims (friends, teachers, mentors) has instilled in me a sense of loyalty and I take any abuse personally. The way these people have been woven into my life has instilled in me a sense of duty and it is incumbent on me to find ways to engage and extract Islamophobia for their defense. I’m not under any illusions,  but a sure path to failure is not to try. Nor do I have any white savior complex, but a mere need to try and do a simple kindness.

Like any prejudice, Islamophobia thrives in ignorance. Over the next few weeks, I’m going to do what I can to shed some light on this subject with an emphasis on history, Orientalism, western imperialism and its aftermath, the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, and terrorism. This is both to provide some resources for anyone interested and to help me organize my thoughts on the matter so I can conduct better dialog with folks in the future.

An added component each week will be an article or piece about the greater problem of prejudicial thinking. What enables it? From where does it derive its strength?

I should add that the Muslims world is expansive, but most of my research and experiences regard the Arab states, spanning the Middle East and North Africa, with a some supplement on the Ottoman-Turks and central Asian peoples.

Middle Eastern Imperialism, Reactions, and Aftermath

In my view, the starting point to a political analysis of the Middle East and North Africa today is the history of Western imperialism. Few parts of the world have been spared this scourge and this region is no different. Most imperialists stories are variants on this narrative: a violent conquest and subjugation justified by an imperial rhetoric of racial and cultural superiority, imposition of an autocratic command structure, a siphoning of the colonized region’s natural resources and labor, a consistent violent suppression of popular resistance, and eventual “decolonization” in the mid-20th century.

Decolonization in quotation marks because these imperial powers often leave behind autocrats with western ties, populations traumatized by violence,  a cultural inferiority complex, economies structured to be reliant on the former imperial power, and oftentimes a large western military presence. Indeed, while these states are nominally independent today, they sometimes strike little contrast to 19th and early 20th century colonial structures and forms of indirect rule, which begs the question: is the age of imperialism really over?

For the Reading List:

Christopher de Bellaigue’s The Islamic Enlightenment, is a book about the Middle East’s struggle against and response to western imperialism. Andrew Lycett’s review breezes over the relevant history and the important cities and leaders covered in the book. This book covers some west-alternative giants: Said Qutub, Hassan al-Banna, and al-Afghani. I studied these three intellectuals in an Contemporary Islamic Thought class at the University of Jordan. For nyone serious about understanding the political landscape of the middle east, the Muslim Brotherhood, and Arab anti-imperialist sentiments, these three intellectuals are required reading  and de Bellaigue’s book appears to be great starting point.

Check your local bookstore, because Frick Amazon, emirite?

Exploring Prejudice

“The Death of Expertise”, Tom Nichols, The Federalist

None of this ignorance stops people from arguing as though they are research scientists. . .This subverts any real hope of a conversation, because it is simply exhausting — at least speaking from my perspective as the policy expert in most of these discussions — to have to start from the very beginning of every argument and establish the merest baseline of knowledge, and then constantly to have to negotiate the rules of logical argument.

Disclaimer: I am not a federalist and take some issue with technocratic conclusions that may or may not be implied, but this article articulates a problem I’ve frequently come up against.

Just about every confrontation I have about Islam comes down to this. Me against an almost complete lack of baseline knowledge. I agree with the author, it’s absolutely exhausting. What’s worse, is how this sort of problem has been playing out, especially recently. The natural and fair response to someone arguing from an imagined authority is to refuse them. Why waste the time? Especially considering how these kinds of people often aren’t arguing in good faith; just want to troll or harass and offend their ‘opponent’.

Unfortunately, ignoring trolls and people arguing in bad faith fuels their culture. I had a family member once retort with that “snowflake” insult, something like ‘Uh-oh, Jimmy’s mad someone disagreed with his worldview”. On a larger, more alarming scale, is how trolls take this refusal to engage as a evidence that they must be right. A friend recently showed me how there are reddit threads devoted to this sort of thing.

This leaves us in a sort of lose-lose situation. Open a dialog with a troll and you fall into a trap of an insulting, unwinnable argument. Refuse this dialog and stoke the flames of ignorance. My best conclusion at this point is that it is worthwhile to hone my debate skills and engage, using tactics to attempt encouraging civil dialog. If its on social media or in an online forum, at the very least anyone else who reads may be able to tell who is reasonable and who is a troll. What do you think?

Weekly Roundup

Julie Johnson: A Legacy of Song“, Bethany Blitz, The Coeur d’Alene Press

The late Julie Johnson spent time teaching in about every elementary school in the Coeur d’Alene School District plus some middle schools. Her passion and joy spread like wildfire to everyone around her.

Now, eight years after her death, her influence is still celebrated at the annual Julie Johnson Jamboree.

“You Shouldn’t Blame Islam for Terrorism. Religion Isn’t A Crucial Factor in Attacks”, Mehdi Hasan, The Intercept

The common stereotype of the Middle Eastern, Muslim-born terrorist is not just lazy and inaccurate, but easy fodder for the anti-immigrant, anti-Islam far right. Consider the swift reaction of White House official Sebastian Gorka to the horrific terror attack in London last week. “The war is real,” he told Fox News while the bodies of the victims were still warm, “and that’s why executive orders like President Trump’s travel moratorium are so important.”

“Meet the Palestinian-American Chef Fighting Cultural Appropriation in Food”, Mona Khalifeh, teenvogue

Abeer Najjar is a South Side Chicagoan, Palestinian, Muslim, chef. Abeer is American.

She is the epitome of what a modern-day American looks like. When you strip away the identifiers, at her core, Abeer is a foodie. From an early age, she had a passion for food. Abeer envisioned having her own cooking show, and while the rest of us were watching Rugrats, Abeer was watching Julia Child. Growing up in the cultural metropolis that is the South Side of Chicago, the typical Palestinian fare Abeer was accustomed to at home was influenced by the foods and cultures of the African, Latino, and Asian friends and neighbors she was surrounded by. Those influences made their way into not only her mother’s cooking but also her own as she took the helm in her home kitchen.

Islamophobia and Antisemetism

“The 712-page Google doc that proves Muslims do condemn terrorism”, Arwa Mahdawi, The Guardian

It happened in history class. Heraa Hashmi, a 19-year-old American Muslim student at the University of Colorado, was supposed to be discussing the Crusades with the man sitting next to her. Within a few minutes, however, he was crusading against Islam.

“Not all Muslims are terrorists, but all terrorists are Muslims,” Hashmi’s classmate told her. What’s more, he complained, not enough Muslims were making a stand against terrorism.

“Two charged with hate crime for attack on Arab teacher outside AIPAC conference”, Jewish Telegraphic Agency

WASHINGTON (JTA) — Two men were charged with a hate crime for an assault on an Arab teacher allegedly carried out by members of the Jewish Defense League outside this week’s AIPAC conference in Washington, D.C.


“More Gazans sick from polluted drinking water, says utility chief”, Sakher Abou El Oun, The Times of Israel

GAZA CITY (AFP) — More and more Gazans are falling ill from their drinking water, highlighting the humanitarian issues facing the Palestinian enclave that the UN says could become uninhabitable by 2020.

“Israeli Soldier’s Explosive Tell-All: “Palestinians are right to resist”, Abby Martin interviews Eran Efrati, Empire Files

“Thousands of Palestinians March to Commemorate Land Day”, Activestills, +972

Screen Shot 2017-04-02 at 1.28.09 PM.png

Hundreds of Palestinians took part in marches across Israel on Wednesday and Thursday to mark “Land Day,” commemorating the six Palestinian citizens killed by Israeli forces in 1976. The events began on Wednesday in a torch-lit march in the northern village of Deir Hanna, and continued Thursday, when hundreds marched in Sakhnin, Araba and Deir Hanna, as well as in the occupied territories.

War and Peace

“Iraq: Civilians killed by airstrikes in their homes after they were told not to flee Mosul”, Amnesty International

Hundreds of civilians have been killed by airstrikes inside their homes or in places where they sought refuge after following Iraqi government advice not to leave during the offensive to recapture the city of Mosul from the armed group calling itself Islamic State (IS), said Amnesty International. Survivors and eyewitnesses in East Mosul said they did not try to flee as the battle got underway because they received repeated instructions from the Iraqi authorities to remain in their homes.

Climate Change and The Environment

“After therapy dog refuses to drink, San Diego unified finds lead in water”, Gary Warth, The Los Angeles Times

A dog’s reluctance to drink from a bowl in a San Diego classroom led to the discovery of lead in the school’s water system, and testing of all pipes in the San Diego Unified School District will begin soon.

American Oligarchy

“David Rockefeller: An Alternative Obituary”, Erik Wallenberg, Jacobin

As a child growing up in a mansion on 54th Street in Manhattan, David Rockefeller remembered roller-skating with his siblings down Fifth Avenue trailed by a limousine in case they got tired. Rockefeller and his family, which included billionaires and politicians at all levels of government, spent a lifetime ensconced in this kind of luxury. At the time of his death on March 20, Forbes estimated that the 101-year-old Rockefeller’s investments in real estate, share of family trusts, and other holdings stood at $3.3 billion.

Democratic Socialism

“IBM’s CEO wrote Trump a glowing letter. Employees responded with a list of demands”, Jack Smith IV, Mic

When IBM’s CEO, Ginni Rometty, wrote a glowing letter to President Donald Trump after his inauguration, it landed poorly, to say the least.

Many used the opportunity to remind the public that IBM collaborated with the Nazis throughout World War II. One senior content strategist quit, writing an open letter about Rometty’s “tacit endorsement” of Trump’s platform.

State Violence and The American Carceral State

“17% Of The Prison Population Has Hepatitis C, Here’s how that could Change”, George Lavender, In These Times

Hepatitis C affects an estimated 1% of the general population but 17% of the prison population. Until relatively recently, treatment for the disease had extremely limited success rates and highly unpleasant side effects. That’s changed with the introduction of new drugs that are significantly more effective at treating the disease.

Unknown Minstrel: Week 4
by Daniel Suhre

A few years back I went to a venue in Washington, D.C. called Rock ‘n’ Roll Hotel to see one of the more popular local groups against my better judgement. I’ll keep them nameless here, but it turns out they were opening for a group unknown to me called Those Darlin’s.

Having very little expectations, as well as a general skepticism towards the Nashville commercialized Americana terrain they were skirting the edge of (albeit in a grunge rock context), I was not looking for much more than a few overpriced beers and a laugh or two.

The group blew me away. The creative energy and guitar chops from the two frontwomen was nothing new, but something about the drawl of lead singer Jessi Zazu mixed with a free flowing, organic feminism really delivered a punch in the vein of Kitty Well’s It wasn’t God who made Honky Tonk Angels or Lesley Gore’s You Don’t Own Me. Listen to That Man (perhaps their response to Gore’s own feminist anthem) performed live:

The group is no longer. Creative differences brought them to the decision to part ways in late 2016, and a week after getting back from their final tour Jessi was diagnosed with cancer. If the outpouring of love in the form of donations to crowd fund her recovery is any indication, the group had a huge cult following and a lot of love in the music community.

Of course, nobody should have to crowd fund their right to medical treatment. #MedicareForAll

Your Essay/Post/Blurb/Whatever Here

I think news blogs are a good idea. I want more people to start doing them. That means you. I want you to start a news blog and include a regular blurb, editorial, or essay that I can add to my blog here. I’ll do one for you in exchange. It is a good idea. So, any interest in starting a news blog? Please contact me. Or tweet @jp124blog


“Get Out”, Jordan Peele
Director: Jordan Peele
Cast: Daniel Kaluuya, Allison Williams, Bradley Whitford

This week I saw Jordan Peele’s Get Out

This horror movie is a nightmarish “Meet the Parents” in which a black man, Chris Wallace (Daniel Kaluuya), goes to meet his white girlfriend Rose Armitage’s (Allison Williams) family on their rural estate. Throughout the film, Chris is subjected racial insensitivies of increasing severity. The first few are benign and can be laughed off, like when Mr. Armitage goes out of his way to say wink and say he’d have voted for Obama a third time, but these insensitivites quickly progress to outright objectification. All of this against a backdrop with some rich, symbolic mise-en-scène.

In my view the social commentary outweighed the scares, but that was no problem as this movie has an important message about cultural appropriation and being black in a white social context. And that’s not to say that the movie isn’t thrilling. Rather, director Peele brilliantly elicits the title phrase from its audience. Throughout the film I couldn’t help urging Chris to “Get out. Get out! Get the fuck OUT!”

Great directorial debut from Jordan Peele. I highly recommend it and am eager to see what more he has to offer (Rumor has it, it might be live action adaptation of Akira).


I’ve caught up on the effort to memorize all the nations and capitals. This week’s additions are:
Antigua and Barbuda — St John’s
Bahamas — Nassau
Barbados — Bridgetown
Dominica — Roseau
Grenada — St. George’s
Saint Kitts and Nevis — Basseterre
Saint Lucia — Castries
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines — Kingstown
Trinidad and Tobago — Port of Spain

Thank you for scrolling

JP124: Chess and Community, and The Silence of the Lambs

the scroll, the scroll,
the buttons, the buttons

The 124

I want to use this space to put a little bit more of myself on the page by editorializing a little bit. I’ve done some of that here, but I want to make it a part of the weekly commitment. A fringe benefit I’m discovering from this whole process is that it’s an exercise in expressing my ideas and that’s a type of growth I’d like more of. That said, I have nothing to type up for you this week. Instead, I’m going to use the space to share a PBS report on local youth development organization Chess and Community. This is a really cool organization and it’s the sort of thing that makes me proud to live in Athens.

Ben & Jerry’s has chosen Chess and Community as their charity for free cone day this April 4th. I’ve been meaning to work on my chess game… hopefully will have a chance to play a game or two after I get my ice cream.

Weekly Roundup…. scroll fast, ‘cuz it’s lengthy

Black Liberation and Left Renewal“, Jordan T. Camp, Jacobin

Drawing on a range of sources that include Martin Luther King, Malcolm X, the Black Panther Party, the Dodge Revolutionary Union Movement, and the Combahee River Collective, Taylor shows how the black freedom movement has historically “pushed mainstream politics to the left.” In sharp contrast to backlash narratives that depict white working-class resistance to civil rights and anger at the 1960s urban uprisings as the source of a punitive turn in politics, she highlights how elites deployed law-and-order strategies to defeat these struggles. The freedom movement, we learn from Taylor, threatened those elites by upending racist stereotypes in service of a reconstruction agenda that would improve material conditions not only for African Americans but for the multiracial working class as a whole.

For Donald Trump, A Terror Attack Will Be An Opportunity Not A Curse“, Peter Maas, The Intercept

Can we breathe a sigh of relief after federal judges blocked President Donald Trump’s discriminatory executive orders? For a moment we can, but we are just a terrorism attack away from the White House gaining a new pretext for its wrathful crackdown against Muslims and immigrants.

Reporter assassinated in Chihuahua capital“, Mexico News Daily

The journalist [Miroslava Breach Velducea] was the third killed in Mexico this month.

Mexico was denounced last month as the most dangerous country in Latin America for journalists. Reporters Without Borders said 99 were assassinated between 2000 and 2016.

American Oligarchy

The Reclusive Hedge-Fund Tycoon Behind the Trump Presidency“, Jane Mayer, The New Yorker

Last month, when President Donald Trump toured a Boeing aircraft plant in North Charleston, South Carolina, he saw a familiar face in the crowd that greeted him: Patrick Caddell, a former Democratic political operative and pollster who, for forty-five years, has been prodding insurgent Presidential candidates to attack the Washington establishment.

He has not worked directly for the President, but at least as far back as 2013 he has been a contractor for one of Trump’s biggest financial backers: Robert Mercer, a reclusive Long Island hedge-fund manager, who has become a major force behind the Trump Presidency.

During the past decade, Mercer, who is seventy, has funded an array of political projects that helped pave the way for Trump’s rise. Among these efforts was public-opinion research, conducted by Caddell, showing that political conditions in America were increasingly ripe for an outsider candidate to take the White House. Caddell told me that Mercer “is a libertarian—he despises the Republican establishment,” and added, “He thinks that the leaders are corrupt crooks, and that they’ve ruined the country.”

The Bizarre Far-Right Billionaire Behind Bannon and Trump’s Presidency“, Thomas Hedges, The Real News Network

In Gorsuch, Conservative Activist Sees Test Case for Reshaping the Judiciary“, Eric Lipton and Jeremy W. Peters, The New York Times

Deep into the Senate’s 68-page questionnaire of Judge Neil M. Gorsuch, the Supreme Court nominee was asked to describe how he had come to President Trump’s attention.

The first thing he wrote was, “I was contacted by Leonard Leo.”


Why the U.S. Women’s Hockey Players are Planning to Strike“, Sarah Jaffe, Dissent

Equal pay for equal work is a demand of women around the globe, yet these athletes—despite dominating their sport in international competition, where only Canada is on their level—get nothing close to it. They make just $20,000 for four years of play. But their demands go beyond wages; theyre also asking for USA Hockey to put money into the sport as a whole, from support for girls youth hockey to marketing for the game.

Afraid of losing their jobs, workers take over the business“, Anna-Catherine Brigida, PRI

Three years into operating as a cooperative, the staff at Los Chanchitos said a day of work is not much different from before. Employees arrive on time for their scheduled shifts, waiters attentively take orders and food is served promptly. But with no owner, decisions are made democratically with consideration for each worker’s concerns.

Discrimination and Hate Crimes

Suspect in Manhattan Killing Hated Black Men, Police Say“, Ashley Southall, The New York Times

An Army veteran with a long-simmering hatred of black men claimed responsibility on Wednesday for using a sword to fatally stab a homeless man in Manhattan this week, the police said, calling the attack random and racially motivated.

US soldier admits killing unarmed Afghans for sport“, Paul Harris, The Guardian

An American soldier has pleaded guilty to being part of a “kill team” who deliberately murdered Afghan civilians for sport last year.

Army Specialist Jeremy Morlock, 23, told a military court he had helped to kill three unarmed Afghans. “The plan was to kill people, sir,” he told an army judge in Fort Lea, near Seattle, after his plea.

Immigration and Deportation

Deportation of African and Other Immigrants Is Quietly Increasing and No One is Taking Note” David Love, Atlanta Black Star

As the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency conducts its sweeps on immigrant communities, African people are among those who are being detained and deported. While deportations were in no short supply under the Obama administration, these deportations are expected to soar under Trump, whose immigration ban on six Muslim nations includes three African nations — Libya, Somalia and Sudan. Trump also is clamping down on refugees and asylum seekers.

War and Peace

War Correspondent Describes U.S. Air Strikes in Iraq, Syria, and Yemen“, Malak Habbak, The Intercept

In Iraq, U.S. forces are helping Iraqi and Kurdish soldiers in their months-long battle to drive ISIS out of western Mosul. As many as 600,000 civilians are trapped there, amid widespread hunger and destruction, and more than 1,000 civilians were killed or injured last month in Iraq.

As Claims Escalate Under Trump, Airwars Tracks 1,000th Alleged Coalition Civilian Casualty Event“, Samuel Oakford, Airwars

Following an unprecedented increase in claims, researchers at Airwars have tracked their 1,000th alleged civilian casualty event tied to reported Coalition strikes in Iraq and Syria. Recent evidence indicates that in both countries, civilian casualties rose during the last months of the Obama administration and are now accelerating further under the presidency of Donald Trump – suggesting possible key changes in US rules of engagement which are placing civilians at greater risk.

US threat to strike North Korea is ‘aimed at Beijing’s ears’” Liu Zhen, South China Morning Post

A pre-emptive strike on North Korea threatened by US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson is most likely just rhetoric to pressure Beijing, analysts say, despite the tension on the peninsula.

Climate Change and The Environment

The Plant Next Door“, Sharon Lerner, The Intercept

When the Environmental Protection Agency informed people in St. John the Baptist Parish, Louisiana, last July that the local neoprene plant was emitting a chemical that gave them the highest risk of cancer from air pollution in the country, the information was received not just with horror and sadness but also with a certain sense of validation.

Flooding, Mudslides Strike Peru, Killing 72; Thousands Homeless“, Pam Wright,

According to the Associated Press, at least 72 people lost their lives and thousands are now homeless after a series of storms wreaked havoc on the South American nation. At least 115,000 homes have been destroyed, roadways are impassable and 117 bridges are reportedly washed out, the report added.

Islamophobia and Antisemitism

Leader of group widely identified as anti-Muslim meets with White House“, Lois Beckett, The Guardian

Brigitte Gabriel, a Lebanese American conservative, has written two books warning about the dangers of “radical Islam”. Act for America, the organization she founded, describes itself as the “the NRA of national security” and claims 500,000 members and 1,000 chapters across the country focused on advancing policies “to protect America from terrorism”.

State Violence

Thousands Protest Police Violence in Paris“, Gonzalo Fuentes, RFI

More than 7,000 people joined the march, which follows the baton rape of 22-year-old Théo Luhaka in a Paris suburb in February and the death in custody of Adama Traoré in Beaumont-sur-Oise last year.

Philippines’ Duterte welcomes prospect of ICC case, says ‘brutal’ war on drugs to go on“, Karen Lema, Reuters

But Duterte has said he is on the right track regarding human rights and has never instructed security forces to kill suspects who were not resisting arrest. More than 8,000 people have died since he took office last year and began his anti-drugs campaign, a third in raids and sting operations by police who say they acted in self-defense.

The Carceral State

Prison labour is a billion-dollar industry, with uncertain returns for inmates“, The Economist

Employment upon release is perhaps the best defence against recidivism. The chief justification for prison labour is that it both defeats idleness and gives inmates marketable skills. Whether it actually does so is unclear. “The vast majority of prison labour is not even cloaked in the idea of rehabilitation,” says Heather Thompson of the University of Michigan. Simple manufacturing jobs, like the ones done cheaply by most inmates, have already left the country. The study pushed by the Bureau of Prisons, showing drops in reoffending, was published in 1996. More recent comparison statistics often ignore bias in how those being studied are chosen. Rigorous academic work on the subject is almost non-existent.

Unknown Minstrel
by Daniel Suhre

This week we take a look at another under-appreciated musician named Gary Stewart. Stewart was a good-timin’ honky tonkin’ man from Kentucky, who never quite achieved wide success. He was “too rock” for country and “too country” for rock.

Despite this Gary did find himself a small but devoted fan base. He was a favorite of Bob Dylan, who said he would listen to ‘Ten Years of This’ over and over again, and the extremely-hard-to-impress critic Robert Christgau called ‘Out of Hand’ “the best regular issue country LP I’ve heard in about five years”.

The song that first drew me in was his more country-rock hit Cactus and a Rose.  There are a few lines in the song that hit me along a certain class line in a way that few other modern country or even folk songs do. See if you can pick them out.

Your Essay Here

A few weeks ago Dan began submitting his blurb Unknown Minstrel to the blog and I think it’s absolutely brilliant. He’s considering starting a blog of his own, an impulse that I’m encouraging, but he currently has other projects that take priority. In the meantime, I want to encourage more people to start news blogs like this one. Moreover, I would like to encourage someone to start up a weekly news blog with an editorial or essay that I can share right here. You interested? Let me know…

al-Baqia (the rest)

Clarice triumphs over sexism:
The feminist theme in The Silence of the Lambs

This week I watched Jonathan Demme’s The Silence of the Lambs, based on the Thomas Harris novel of the same name. This movie is well-known enough that I feel little obligation to go over the plot, so I’ll make it quick and then get to my thoughts on its feminist theme.

FBI trainee Clarice Starling is called in by mentor and role model, behavioral specialist Jack Crawford. Crawford assigns Clarice to go interview cannibalistic serial killer Hannibal Lecter in order to gain insight into at large serial killer Buffalo Bill, nicknamed because he skins his female victims. Lecter, who speaks to no one, takes an interest in Clarice and offers insight quid pro quo, in exchange for information about Clarice’s life. This relationship pays off and Clarice is able to solve Dr. Lecter’s riddles in order to find and kill Buffalo Bill, save his most recent victim, and graduate from the FBI academy.

The Silence of the Lambs is a story about FBI trainee Clarice Starling’s triumph over sexism. This conflict plays out both in her successive encounters with sexism in her professional life and then, of course, against the movie’s villain Buffalo Bill who is a personification of violence against and hatred of women.

The movie introduces Clarice in what will be a fairly consistent form: busting her ass to overcome obstacles. In this first instance she’s literally on the FBI obstacle course. This is the form of the movie, throughout which Clarice is relentless in her pursuit of Buffalo Bill and need to prove herself, facing down benevolent sexism and casual disregard from her her respected mentor Jack Crawford, who means well and put Clarice on the case, but ultimately lets us down; belittlement from the correctional director Chilton, who believes she was put on the case solely to tantalize Dr. Lecter and turns from accommodating to cold when Clarice asserts her independence as an investigator;  aggressive sexual harassment from an inmate who later flings semen at her; and the resentment of a roomful of local police, who acknowledge her authority, but clearly don’t respect it. Ironically, and brilliantly imo, the only man in the entire movie who shows Clarice the respect she deserves is depicted to be a monster: the sociopath psychoanalyst serial killer who eats his victims, Hannibal “the cannibal ” Lecter.

Director Jonathan Demme sets up an excellent juxtaposition to introduce Dr. Lecter. The path to Hannibal is a gauntlet beginning with a long descent down and down into the depths of the Baltimore State Hospital for the Criminally Insane, which is paired with melodramatic scoring as we’re told of how Hannibal faked chest pains and used the opportunity to brutalize a nurse, during which “his pulse never got above 85.“, all the guards are tense and uneasy, together with Chilton they piece together a monstrous mythology — this man is evil. The final stretch is a row of violent and repulsive inmates before finally arriving at the startling contrast: Hannibal the Cannibal is remarkably likable; someone who’s respect you’d want to earn.

Not only is Dr. Lecter the only man in the film who respects Clarice, but Clarice is the only person in the film who he takes an interest in at all. Everybody else is either a bother or food to him. After escaping prison, Dr. Lecter calls Clarice to congratulate her on the case and to let her know that he has no intent to come after because “the world’s more interesting with you in it”. This is the devil affirming the film’s message that women deserve their place in the world. It’s a striking choice. I suppose that it represents how deep you have to go to subvert an established order? Not sure.

While the antagonist in the movie is sexism itself, it is grotesquely manifested in the movie’s villain, Buffalo Bill, a  serial killer who skins women to make a suit for himself to enable the transformation he desires. Dr. Lecter makes point of clarifying that Buffalo Bill isn’t a transexual, but actually is disturbed and seeks a transformation that removes him from himself.

This brings up a common criticism against the film and one that I’m sympathetic to: it’s transphobic. The the status of trans people and the rampant violence against trans women in this country, 8 murdered in the US so far this year and 27 last year, is why Hannibal’s disclaimer — that Bill isn’t actually trans —  isn’t enough and I determine this choice to have been irresponsible. Transphobia isn’t intended to be part of the movie’s message, clearly, but unintended consequences are relevant and demand attention. It brings to mind how some so-called feminists actively exclude trans women.

Regardless, The Silences of the Lambs is an entertaining thriller in which a powerful woman faces and overcomes sexism with dogged determination and brilliant professional intuition. It holds up well and is well worth a visit or revisit. Let me know if you watch it and what you think!


I’m catching up and will be back on track with progress on the effort to memorize all the nations and capitals next week.

Thank you for scrolling

March 18, 2017: Love, Henry Wallace, and Cowboy Bebop

Okay three, two, one, let’s jam…


Henry A. Wallace“,

Wallace was a strong supporter of New Deal liberalism, and softer policies towards the Soviet Union. His public feuds with other officials and unpopularity with party bosses in major cities caused significant controversy during his time as Vice President under Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the midst of World War II, and resulted in Democrats dropping him from the ticket in the 1944 election in favor of Senator Harry S Truman. In the 1948 presidential election, Wallace left the Democratic Party to run unsuccessfully as the nominee of the Progressive Party against Truman, Republican Thomas E. Dewey, and States’ Rights Democrat Strom Thurmond. He won 2.4% of the popular vote and no electoral votes, and finished fourth.

The 124

Henry Wallace, America’s Forgotten Visionary“, Peter Dreier, Truthout

One of the great “What if?” questions of the 20th century is how America would have been different if Henry Wallace rather than Harry Truman had succeeded Franklin Roosevelt in the White House.

Untold History: The Rise and Fall of a Progressive Vice-President of the USA“, Paul Jay interviewing Peter Kuznick, The Real News Network

Weekly Roundup

What if Instead of Leaning In, Women in Tech Just Left?“, Rachel Siemens, Man Repeller

Tech and start-up culture is as notorious for its workforce skewing white and male as it is for craft beers and the consideration of in-office ping pong as a legitimate part of a benefits package (one might even make the leap to say that the former is the reason for the latter). With the current graduation rate at 20% for female engineers, this leaves the few women who enter the tech industry to experience everything from isolation to objectification in what is ostensibly a nerd-flavored boys’ club.

But what if there was another option? What if women just left?

Cambodia Outraged as US Demands Repayment of ‘Blood-Stained’ War Debt“, Nika Knight, Common Dreams

you can’t make this stuff up…

Cambodians are responding with outrage to the U.S. government’s demand that the country repay a nearly 50-year-old loan to Cambodia’s brutal Lon Nol government, which came to power through a U.S.-backed coup and spent much of its foreign funds purchasing arms to kill its own citizens, according to Cambodia’s current prime minister Hun Sen.

 “Years of federal scrutiny lead to Caterpillar HQ raid“, Ally Marotti, Chicago Tribune

Authorities from three agencies, including the Internal Revenue Service, arrived before 11 a.m. at the headquarters and two nearby facilities. Initially only confirming the raid, Caterpillar later in the day acknowledged it was tied to the same issue that has dogged the company for eight years: its use of a parts subsidiary based in Switzerland and tax-saving practices that sparked a Senate investigation, shareholder lawsuits and a $1 billion penalty.

Confronting Academia’s Ties to Slavery“, Jennifer Schuessler, The New York Times

Harvard had been “directly complicit” in slavery, Ms. Faust acknowledged, before moving to a more present-minded statement of purpose.

“Only by coming to terms with history,” she said, “can we free ourselves to create a more just world.”

The gathering, which featured a keynote address by the writer Ta-Nehisi Coates, drew an overflow crowd of about 500, including researchers from more than 30 campuses.

 This Week in the Executive: Antisemitism

Exclusive: Nazi-Allied Group Claims Top Trump Aide Sebastian Gorka as Sworn Member“, Lili Bayer and Larry Cohler-Esses, Forward

Sebastian Gorka, President Trump’s top counter-terrorism adviser, is a formal member of a Hungarian far-right group that is listed by the U.S. State Department as having been “under the direction of the Nazi Government of Germany” during World War II, leaders of the organization have told the Forward.

Discrimination and Hate Crimes

Salem man arrested in suspected hate crime attack on Middle Eastern restaurant“, Samantha Matsumoto, The Oregonian

A Salem man is charged with assault and intimidation after he allegedly attacked an employee at a Middle Eastern restaurant with a pipe Tuesday afternoon, police said.

Texas Senate passes bill curbing bathroom access based on ‘biological sex’“, Lauren McGaughy, The Dallas Morning News

Republicans and one Democrat, you say?

AUSTIN — The Texas Senate has officially passed the so-called bathroom bill, a controversial measure that has divided lawmakers and caused an uproar in the LGBT community.

After more than 4 1/2 hours of debate Tuesday, the bill was given preliminary approval by a vote of 21-10, mostly along party lines. One Democrat, Sen. Eddie Lucio Jr. of Brownsville, broke with his party and voted in favor of the bill.

 Immigration and Deportation

Army Veteran who served two tours in Afghanistan is fighting deportation to Mexico after he was arrested for delivering two pounds of cocaine“, Cheyenne Roundtree, Daily Mail

  • Miguel Perez, Jr. is facing deportation despite his permanent resident status
  • He served in Afghanistan for the Army and lived in the U.S. since he was eight
  • The 38-year-old was convicted of a non-violent drug charge in Chicago in 2010
  • Perez thought he earned citizenship status since he served in the military
  • His parents, who are U.S. citizens, are fighting his deportation back to Mexico

Thousands of ICE detainees claim they were forced into labor, a violation of anti-slavery laws“, Kristine Phillips, The Washington Post

The lawsuit, filed in 2014 against one of the largest private prison companies in the country, reached class-action status this week after a federal judge’s ruling. That means the case could involve as many as 60,000 immigrants who have been detained.

Thousands of undocumented immigrants said they were forced to work for $1 a day or less“, Circa News

A lawsuit claiming immigrants detained by U.S. Customs and Immigration Enforcement were forced into slave labor, originally filed in 2014, reached class-action status earlier this week.

Trump has opened his arms to immigrants, but only if they’re white Canadians“, Robert Fisk, The Independent

Faced with an avalanche of tourist cancellations from Canada and Europe now that the Trump regime is settling into a racist border policy, congressmen are desperately hoping that the Promoting Tourism to Enhance our Economy Act will help to keep the cash flowing into America – because it aims to let Canadians of 55 and over who own or rent property in the US stay there for an extra two months a year. The 55-year old lower age limit for property owners or renters suggests to you that wealthy white Canadians might be the tourists which Republicans (and Democrats, one should add) have in mind.

And you’d be right.

Poverty and Class Warfare

6 in 10 Americans don’t have $500 in savings“, Kathryn Vasel, CNNMoney

Only 41% of adults reported having enough in their savings account to cover a surprise bill of this magnitude. A little more than 20% said they would put it on a credit card, the report said, while 20% would cut their spending and 11% would turn to friends and family for financial assistance.

Amid Humanitarian Funding Gap, 20 Million People across Africa, Yemen at risk of Starvation, Emergency Relief Chief Warns Security Council”, United Nations

Twenty million people across four countries faced starvation and famine if the international community did not act quickly, the United Nations humanitarian chief warned the Security Council today, expressing alarm at the funding gap to meet the needs in Yemen, South Sudan, Somalia and north-eastern Nigeria.


Israel imposes ‘apartheid regime’ on Palestinians: U.N. report“, Reuters

A U.N. agency published a report on Wednesday accusing Israel of imposing an “apartheid regime” of racial discrimination on the Palestinian people, and said it was the first time a U.N. body had clearly made the charge.

Bernie Sanders

Bernie Sanders remains one of America’s most popular politicians“, Philip Bump, The Washington Post

 A fascinating new survey from Fox News asked Americans their opinions of a number of political leaders and politically relevant organizations. No elected official included in the survey had a larger net favorability — overall favorable views minus unfavorable ones — than Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), continuing Sanders’s strong showing in such polls.

Somewhat surprisingly, the second-highest net favorability was held by Planned Parenthood.

5 Remarkable Moments from Bernie Sanders’ Town Hall in the Heart of Coal Country“, Alexandra Rosenmann, Alternet

Chris Hayes is sometimes insufferable, but. . .

Sen. Bernie Sanders hosted a panel discussion in McDowell County, West Virginia, Monday night on MSNBC’s “All in With Chris Hayes.” And as he did in his Kenosha, Wisconsin talk earlier this year, Sanders succeeded where so many Democrats failed this past election cycle—by connecting with red-state voters.

Unknown Minstrel — Week 2
by Dan Suhre

Recently I’ve found myself wanting to learn more about labor movements and the history of labor unions in the United States. What little exposure I’ve had to labor history mostly came from Howard Zinn’s “A People’s History of the United States”, a text I’ve wanted to go back to for a while.

Interestingly enough, many of the places close to where I grew up in northern Idaho, Montana, and Washington State, were battlegrounds for organized labor in the early 20th century, and yet little to no time in my high school history classes was devoted to the subject.

So this week I wanted to highlight Utah Phillips, a member of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) and a self-identifying anarchist (not some liberal-darling, city-slicker folkie mind you). Listen to Utah’s memorial to early twentieth century songwriter and labor activist Joe Hill.

In 1930 Alfred Hayes wrote a song about Joe Hill that would later be covered by Phil Ochs, Pete Seeger, Joan Baez, and many others. The song itself is beautiful to listen to, but I like hearing Utah’s soft-spoken tribute from a fellow Wobbly (member of the IWW).

It’s striking to me the brutality with which the government and powerful interests conspired to silence and kill many labor heroes. One doesn’t often think about the United States as having a violent and bloody labor history, but the reality tells a different story. Now that the heroic Standing Rock struggle has awoken a new will to fight the powerful interests of the state, it’s important to look back at our rich history of rabble-rousers and the songs they inspired.

al-Baqia (The Rest)

The True Hard Work of Love and Relationships“, Krista Tippet interviews Alain de Botton, On Being

Botton: I think that a functioning society requires two things that, again, just don’t sound very normal, but they require love and politeness. And by “love” I mean a capacity to enter imaginatively into the minds of people with whom you don’t immediately agree, and to look for the more charitable explanations for behavior which doesn’t appeal to you and which could seem plain wrong, not just to chuck them immediately in prison or to hold them up in front of a law court. . .

. . . The other thing, of course, is politeness, which is an attempt not necessarily to say everything, to understand that there is a role for private feelings, which if they were to emerge, would do damage to everyone concerned. But we’ve got this culture of kind of self-disclosure. And as I say, it spills out into politics as well. The same dynamic goes on of, like, “If I’m not telling you exactly what I think, then I may develop a twitch or an illness from not expunging my feelings.” To which I would say, “No, you’re not. You’re preserving the peace and the good nature of the republic, and it’s absolutely what you should be doing.”

Cowboy Bebop – The Meaning of Nothing“, Channel Criswell

I was surfing movie reviews on youtube, which is a new post-FB pastime of mine, and I came across this interesting analysis of the characters in Cowboy Bebop. The video maybe runs a little long, but his analysis hits on the lyrical quality that can be found in episodic story-telling in general and the powerful “existential drift” told over the course of this series in particular.

This show is important to me. I first encountered it by accident when I was 14. I fell asleep on the couch watching Cartoon Network and when I woke up, there was this show that immediately made me uncomfortable because of how adult the animation was. I knew right away that this wasn’t normal programming. I was further unnerved when the commercial break revealed I was watching something called ‘adult swim’. I briefly worried that I had stumbled into some twisted pornographic late night realm. Nonetheless, I finished the episode, which intrigued me and captured my imagination. Unfortunately, my family was on a month-long trial of digital cable which ended that week and I didn’t resume watching until three years later when I bought the series on bootleg DVD.

I’ve watched Cowboy Bebop in its entirety 3-5 times in the last decade or so. It’s just that good. Not only is Spike “Whatever happens, happens” Spiegel  the Platonic form of cool, there’s also brilliant animation, characters, music,  action, a jaw-dropping series finale, and the potent saudade that the show evokes. There’s a sequence towards the end  — the one with the eggs for those of you ‘in the know’ — that begins reconciling the character arcs and hinting that it’s time to say goodbye. I think it’s one of the most moving sequences in television. Love this show and watching this review has cued yet another need to re-watch the series.


Still on a break! I’ve fallen off the nations of the week wagon for two weeks and am just now climbing back on, but now I have to catch up. Should be adding 10-15 countries again in 1-2 weeks.

See you space cowboy…